Big To Do
About Us

“Saving Love Lives The World Over!” e-mail e-mail to a friend in need

September 23, 2008

Can’t afford to stay, can’t afford to leave

Filed under: Treats — posted by Breakup Girl @ 9:23 am

Here, from FOBG Mary Beth Williams at Salon.com, a dismaying/touching account of the penny-pinch of heartbreak:

Sep. 22, 2008 | My marital separation would be so much easier if I were in a better income bracket. Then again, if I were in a better income bracket, maybe my husband and I wouldn’t be separating at all. I could rattle off all the reasons why the man that I promised to love forever is not sleeping next to me tonight. I can list all the heartaches we’ve endured over the last two years. Or I could cut to the chase and tell you that this is a story about money.

We saved and scrimped and searched for three years before sinking everything we had and more into a home for ourselves and our two children, a tiny co-op in a fringy New York City neighborhood. The process left us emotionally and financially tapped. Then, three days before we closed on the apartment, my husband lost his job.

Ultimately, it wasn’t the mortgage or job search or the way we both had to hustle for freelance work or the piled-up bills that did us in, although those things were a kick in the teeth. All those indignities we might have endured, though, had we endured them together. Instead, the stress and the pain and the lost self-esteem and inevitable and often crippling psychic toll of our strained circumstances contaminated our lives and brought out something in both of us that we couldn’t come back from. The harder we tried to be brave, the further apart we grew.

It may well be that if this financial and subsequent emotional crisis hadn’t driven a wedge between us, something else would have eventually done the job. It’s certainly fair to say that we’re not the same people we were when we married a decade and a half ago, in our mid-20s. But even if our financial disasters weren’t the cause of our breakup, they sure were the catalyst.

Yet they’ve likewise made us think long and hard about the consequences of ending it. I have spent hours at my desk, ruefully contemplating my Quicken spreadsheet, calculating my monthly income and expenses, trying to make the numbers turn out better. Emotionally, I couldn’t afford to stay in this marriage any longer. Financially, I don’t know how I’ll be able to afford to leave it.

Before I actually became one of those people whose marriage breaks up, I had a very simplistic notion of separation. It was a scene in a movie, one where the music swells and a woman stands tearfully looking out a window while a man in an overcoat tosses a suitcase into a taxi. Here’s the reality: It’s not like checking out of a hotel. And if it’s a movie, it’s more like “Dead Man Walking. ”

Long after we first broached the painful subject, my husband and I were still planning how to finesse our separation. It took weeks of discussion and more than one heavily annotated chart. Grief is not merely quantifiable; it can be PowerPointed. On the upside, the logistics of our unraveling have spurred us to communicate with a candor and spirit of cooperation that has been friendlier and more generous than almost anything that precipitated it. And it forced us to rely, heavily, on the charity of others.

Our separation is not a tidy business of someone going off to his quaint bachelor digs. Mostly my husband has been staying with his elderly parents, a few towns over, an arrangement that nobody’s enthusiastic about. At other times, we’ve cobbled together alternative accommodations. When our friends down the hall went away for two weeks, we traded off staying in their apartment, a situation that was unusual but which provided maximum access to our children. Later we made plans for him to stay at a Brooklyn musician friends’ apartment, but when the guy’s tour was canceled, we were sent scrambling for last-minute backup options. We’ve even had an awkward night when I went to a play with a girlfriend, returning late and sleeping on the couch while he slept in our bedroom. And if you’re looking for me next week, I will be taking up residence in another friend’s Upper West Side apartment during her vacation. This isn’t just a separation; it’s the Separation World Tour 2008, sponsored by Samsonite and the New York City Metropolitan Transit Authority.

We still split the expenses. When I think about shouldering them alone I can barely breathe. I can’t pay a mortgage single-handedly. I don’t even know if I can give up our family phone plan. Some days, I look at the bills and wonder, is losing my rollover minutes the price I have to pay for freedom? He and I have conversations galore, but we still haven’t figured anything out that feels equitable and practical.

I have lived most of my adult on a limited income, have budgeted and penny-pinched and done without. I rarely go to restaurants or buy new clothes. Yet even the few indulgences I once enjoyed — a once-a-week mocha, an occasional new book — now feel out of reach. I am taking the pittance I put aside every month for my daughters’ college education and redirecting it toward the day-to-day cost of living. I watch as the shabby IKEA kitchen cabinets sag precariously. They will likely soon fall apart completely, and I don’t know how I’ll ever be able to replace them. The fridge is on the fritz. They need school supplies and fall clothes. Beats me how it’ll happen. The burden of this choice, the potential for utter ruin, haunts me constantly.

Breakups are painful and crappy even in the best of circumstances. My two close friends of reasonably independent financial means rail over the endless minutiae of splitting expenses with their exes. My happily remarried college pal still describes her youthful divorce as “an amputation.” They’re the ones who got off easier. Another friend and her estranged husband had to live together for two years in a miserable state of marital limbo, because they simply couldn’t afford to split up the family. And a fellow mom from the playground confided recently that she’s spent the past year wanting to leave her marriage, but how could she and her kids survive on her salary?

In most of history and even now in most of the world, a woman walking away from a marriage has been unthinkable. Autonomy is rarely an option. Hell, I’m doing it, and it still feels like a long shot. I’m still not convinced that the mere possibility of mutual happiness apart from each other is a noble or practical enough goal. I worry that I am limiting my children’s lives, that in addition to all the emotional baggage of not having Mom and Dad across from them at the dinner table, they will have to make all kinds of material sacrifices they didn’t sign up for. I ask myself every day if my kids would be happier with two brave souls sticking it out but keeping them more secure than they could possibly be with a primary caregiver whose chances of plummeting into poverty just went through the occasionally leaky roof.

And yet, when I was still in the contemplative stage of the process, the notion of staying in something because it was more financially advantageous struck me as hopelessly cynical and downright mean. I saw us growing older and sadder. I saw something that had been wonderful and good and loving for so long becoming twisted into something mercenary and suffocating, dwindling into a joyless splitting of the electricity bill and the groceries. I saw two goodhearted people, who had brought two hilarious and beautiful children into the world, at a point when the only right and kind thing to do seemed to be to take the craziest fiscal gamble imaginable. I couldn’t save my marriage. I am having a hell of a time saving money. But I might be able to save, at least, the rest of our lives.

— By Mary Elizabeth Williams


  1. I loved as much as you will obtain carried out right here. The cartoon is attractive, your authored subject matter stylish. nonetheless, you command get got an impatience over that you would like be delivering the following. sick definitely come more previously again since precisely the similar just about very often within case you defend this increase.
    arcteryx hyllus

    Comment by arcteryx hyllus — October 25, 2016 @ 12:14 am

  2. The use of sun glasses should be avoided. As a leader, you can decide for your group provided that you are authorized to do so. Another option is really a draping wrap dress – pregnant women who desires to flaunt their pregnancy can place the wrap dress a little more tightly, whilst those who do not wish to phone attention to their belly might tie the actual encapsulate dress usually. The choice of underlay is huge for use when floating the floor all of which are adequate.Then join CyberShoppers in direction of list shopping for very good deals in front your popular goods or toward agenda turning your undomesticated unhealthy into little cash.
    Cheap Jerseys [url=http://www.jerseyschina.us.com/]Cheap Jerseys[/url]

    Comment by Cheap Jerseys — October 25, 2016 @ 2:17 am

  3. Very carefully read the little produce in your credit records. The Braves made the most important move in the front office. 3. In fact they are going to do things you never even dreamed of: throwing golf balls at each other, slamming clubs on the ground, hitting when someone is in front of them, climbing trees, etc. Following letting it stay, clean your lip area and rub them with almond oils.
    Cheap Jerseys Wholesale

    Comment by Cheap Jerseys Wholesale — October 25, 2016 @ 3:52 am

  4. hermes garden party uk history facts Breakup Girl » Can’t afford to stay, can’t afford to leave hermes belt throw up

    Comment by hermes belt throw up — October 25, 2016 @ 4:25 am

  5. moncler buena vista

    Comment by la face nord — October 25, 2016 @ 5:37 am

  6. A secondproblem would have been transportation to my school. But, in reality, the root cause of glaucoma is a highly toxiccondition of the system due to dietetic errors, a faulty life style and the prolonged use ofsuppressive drugs for the treatment of other diseases. This is a very stable method, which is the recommended option for most solid wood and parquet floors. Though in school, we are being taught how to become independent and competitive against other students. The surgery went well.
    Wholesale Jerseys

    Comment by Wholesale Jerseys — October 25, 2016 @ 9:49 am

  7. If you are playing a mobile app that is free to
    download, but has numerous advertisements, zero incentive for you to watch video ads or interrupts your gameplay with ridiculous goals
    that you can’t possibly achieve unless you fork
    over cash, my recommendation is to just delete that app and move on to something else.
    The problem with shooters is that less strategy is
    involved. The You – Wave Emulator has to be installed in your PC if
    you want to download android applications in your computer.

    Also visit my homepage … clash of clans hack (http://www.intaskrnd.com/)

    Comment by http://www.intaskrnd.com/ — October 25, 2016 @ 11:08 am

  8. Who do you want to gift for wholesale Anthony Barr jerseys?
    Get value into the page: http://qiaoyanshengwu.com/comment/html/index.php?page=1&id=79147

    Comment by http://qiaoyanshengwu.com/comment/html/index.php?page=1&id=79147 — October 25, 2016 @ 6:20 pm

  9. I knew my key sales people in all of ou Baker, Bobby Jones, Jack Nicklaus, Claiborne, DKNY Donna Karan New York, Pierre, Cardin, Perry Elliproviding you with excellent personal service and great online shopping experience.

    Comment by Ray Ban RB7788 Wayfarer Black — October 25, 2016 @ 6:33 pm

  10. There are several lotions that will promote adults to appear youthful in a natural way!View this print supposing that you would need to get acquainted with how could you be youthful without surgery.The injury occurred on Miller’s first and only pitch of the game, which was lined back at him by Braves pinchhitter Willians Astudillo. Minecraft has two kinds of game play, Singleplayer and Multiplayer. Your emotions and thoughts will always be reflected in the word and circumstances you create in your life.com/forsale.

    Comment by Kwadwo Asamoah Jersey UK — October 25, 2016 @ 8:16 pm

  11. dcr. Butler why he been given an government producer credit mainly because I am a member belonging to the Producers Guild and this is usually an issue and when he earned it, I wanted to invite him to become a member of our firm.kettlebellbootcamp. If your instructor get you to do a lot of lying triceps extension, french curls or bicep curls, it is time to look somewhere else for a much more qualified instructor. In the rules of b?Kettlebell is one of the most popular fitness trend in 2009 according to a survey conducted by the American Council on Exercise (ACE), the America s authority in fitness.

    Comment by Mikel Arteta Jersey — October 25, 2016 @ 8:17 pm

  12. The more runs that are scored, the better the game is to watch. We love having dogs here as long as their owners obey the rules, says Bill Beach, assistant office manager. Only use the lower part of your body to slide, otherwise you will more than likely injure yourself.com Publicado por copito en 14:14 No hay comentarios: VICTIMA DE MEDICO GASTROENTEROLOGO Tenga mucho cuidado cuando se practique un procedimiento m?dico.Author’s Resource BoxCourtesy of Jules Hawk.

    Comment by Vlade Divac Jersey — October 25, 2016 @ 8:21 pm

  13. 3.Make sure you understand how a baseball field is designed for play. Other email features can include PGP Encryption, Personal SMTP Mail Server and the ability to use Email Auto Responders.state.* Website Monitoring – To monitor the activity of your website, many firms offer Daily Data Backups, access to downloadable Raw Access Logs and the use of Wusage 7.

    Comment by http://www.thenflshopuk.com/Minnesota-Vikings-Adrian-Peterson-Jersey/ — October 25, 2016 @ 8:32 pm

  14. Nonetheless, even delegating somebody to open up the mail can be quite a huge time saver. This is completed so by celebrating their birthdays by holding big celebrations for buddies and relatives. For that reason, you must manage your time as well as delegate the nonproductive essential material to somebody else.HCMillerPress. Only work on the appliances which are assembled using bolts, screws and plugs.
    Cheap Jerseys From China

    Comment by Cheap Jerseys From China — April 18, 2017 @ 8:38 pm

  15. Had some change that fell out of my jacket pocket Guy behind me was

    Comment by ideas for baby shower invitations for a girl — April 20, 2017 @ 7:54 am

  16. ray ban sunglasses outlet online

    Comment by http://ray-bansunglassescheapsale.com/sitemap.html — April 20, 2017 @ 1:59 pm

  17. adidas yeezy boost 350 release

    Comment by yeezy boost 350 for sale — April 20, 2017 @ 4:54 pm

  18. Nonetheless, it may be the problem and should not be left out when the parts of the device are been checked out for faulty operation. A consultancyservice may advise on anything from space requirements, to how toprepare the team for the integration, and to avoid a learning curve thatcould slow production times.Many companies do not eventhin k about buying used printing equipment, not because they don’tthink it’s a good idea but because they don’t know where to startlooking.The bankruptcy assistance in opposition to bankruptcyDebt support in the variety of the bankruptcy advice can be utilized very first from virtually any lawyer that deals in this specific issue. This is what causes the development of a deep color that resembles a suntan.

    Comment by Cheap Jerseys China — April 21, 2017 @ 10:59 am

  19. Ugg boot 1st disigned for young girls, so girls ugg boot would be the principal area related to Ugg market.If not, create your own play, complete with script, costumes and makeup!Action!9. Allow someone else edit and publish the book.The Benefits Of Flexographic Printing Presses From HC Miller Press » StrongPedia Article Directory – Free article directory. Just one term of caution though,North Face Vest Sale frequently make particular the fact on the web store you’re buying from is genuinely an associate for the Australian Sheepskin Association.
    Cheap Jerseys Free Shipping China

    Comment by Cheap Jerseys Free Shipping China — April 21, 2017 @ 11:21 am

  20. Luckily you can have this carried out at the Treasure Hunters Roadshow for free of charge. In testing the functionality of the outlet, voltage tester is necessary. Only work on the appliances which are assembled using bolts, screws and plugs.5 percent of our house complete at closing, but the last .Many supplements a???l?bl? will a?s? not u?? 100% genuine ingredients w?t? many using cheap fillers th?t not ?nly reduce t?? effectiveness of t?? supplement but may a?so b? unsafe to use.

    Comment by Wholesale Jerseys — April 21, 2017 @ 6:14 pm

  21. With the current problems in the mortgage market, banks and the federal governments have reached consensus to help homeowners, but often the mortgage servicers, having the ultimate power to modify a mortgage, refuse to ?play ball?. This can give you a clear picture of that which you have done and the work that you have remaining to do.The main reason as to why these schools are established is so as to give those that have no funds to pay for their education, a chance to also go through school just like any other student. Read on for tips about running a home business. For appliances which need oven operation, the fuse is separate and plug-type.
    Cheap Jerseys China

    Comment by Cheap Jerseys China — April 21, 2017 @ 6:45 pm

  22. They aren’t just popular among the youthful generation only but adults also enjoy actively playing them a lot.Finding your gold coins valuated is the very first point that you need to have to do. The loans are generally used on the basis of becoming credit card. Students under sponsorship who do not perform are deprived of the privilege which is then granted to the deserving people. The objective is to adjust mortgages so homeownerspayments remain affordable.
    Wholesale NFL Jerseys

    Comment by Wholesale NFL Jerseys — April 21, 2017 @ 6:46 pm

  23. 35 million Robbie Keane, Los Angeles Galaxy: $4. La tuve yo ?.Game developers bear caught the trend, in addition especially created virtual gun plus a virtual real estate that definitely will not continue to be purchased without taking towards expend indicative it isle statement real money. They were much more unified than they are today. Author Resource: SEO providers can design websites that are easy to load and navigate.
    Marouane Fellaini Jersey

    Comment by Marouane Fellaini Jersey — April 22, 2017 @ 1:06 am

  24. Sometimes it can be difficult to establish no matter if or not your teaching program is too strenuous for the cardiovascular system.James Malinchak, Featured on ABC’s Hit Tv Show Secret Millionaire, is considered by many people experts as the World’s #1 Big Money Speaker Coach and Trainer. All your relatives would surely be in for a treat on that day! Author Resource:-Visit our site for more information: Cotton Candy Machine, Bouncy Castle, Bouncy Castle Rental.There ?r? many companies online w?? ?r? ?n?y ?o?k?ng f?r y?u t? sign u? t? t???r auto-ship program. Further, they are increasingly turning to consumer abuses to collect mortgage payments, at a time when working with and helping out distressed consumers would obviously be in everyone?s best interests.
    Cheap Discount Jerseys

    Comment by Cheap Discount Jerseys — April 22, 2017 @ 2:35 am

  25. Maintenance UGGs in correct approach is also become a growing number of significant.Part of the problem is that there is little regulation of the mortgage servicing industry and therefore there are significant abuses that go unchecked. Students under sponsorship who do not perform are deprived of the privilege which is then granted to the deserving people.However, City Hall can be a great place to talk to kids about the local lawmakers, while showing them the courts and politicians of the city.You can make self-portraits, a family painting or a family mural.

    Comment by Wholesale Jerseys — April 22, 2017 @ 10:01 am

  26. Such as this, Right for you much more effortless and you might own additional decisions. When the primary ingredient listed says “whole”, the item is really a good source of whole grains. An excellent choice is search Uggs.You can’t continue to keep at the pace you’re going whilst doing what you are doing. This is completed so by celebrating their birthdays by holding big celebrations for buddies and relatives.
    Cheap Jerseys

    Comment by Cheap Jerseys — April 22, 2017 @ 10:51 am

  27. These tanners rely on what’s called dihydroxyacetone or DHA.” The collectible (numismatic) coins can be significantly larger price based on the industry.When everybody knows that will cleanup UGG boot styles with the distinctive store bills money and additionally moment. Just one term of caution though,North Face Vest Sale frequently make particular the fact on the web store you’re buying from is genuinely an associate for the Australian Sheepskin Association. Real uggs are sensible footwear for all seasonTo convey Ugg boots are one of the most favored design sneakers influences during the past Decade seriously isn t an exaggeration.
    Cheap Jerseys China

    Comment by Cheap Jerseys China — April 22, 2017 @ 10:52 am

  28. As quickly when you begin to feel any kind of pain, you should stop exercising and ice your muscles down. She has an advanced degree in engineering and over twenty years making technology decisions for fortune 500 companies.Have no fear! The following is a list of engaging activities for you and your children to enjoy together. The objective is to adjust mortgages so homeownerspayments remain affordable.com/.

    Comment by Cheap Nike NFL Jerseys — April 22, 2017 @ 5:27 pm

  29. These uggs not only provide comfort however are very adaptable simultaneously. Aside from the basics like getting multiple bids and asking for references, my husband and I learned that the questions we asked at the beginning of the process had a tremendous impact on the outcome of the project.Would you like me to be available as a reference? Setting an expectation up front that you would be willing to be a reference and to allow the builder to show your home to prospective clients can help smooth the road for your project and have your builder focus on keeping you happy.You can make self-portraits, a family painting or a family mural. these tools won’t help you finish your favorite game first however, you also get to win it as well.
    Cheap Jerseys Outlet

    Comment by Cheap Jerseys Outlet — April 22, 2017 @ 6:17 pm

  30. and showed that the regular American spends ahead online games 23. A seawall that’s produced applying galvanized metal can last more than any metal that’s maybe not sprayed to stop rust. (Especially a city you would want to visit!)For the more active retirees, there are options for adventure. It’s a question of time. If you have the kind of parents that cant stand to be still, you may consider packing them uEden Hazard Close To Record Contract At Chelsea RealGM WiretapEden Hazard is close to signing a new contract with Chelsea that would pay him £200,000 per week.
    Hakeem Olajuwon Jersey

    Comment by Hakeem Olajuwon Jersey — April 22, 2017 @ 8:52 pm

  31. com Publicado por copito en 14:14 No hay comentarios: VICTIMA DE MEDICO GASTROENTEROLOGO Tenga mucho cuidado cuando se practique un procedimiento m?dico. You would like your dog to view you as the innovator, so they need to commence to walk at the rear of you. He is a good psychologist.One common type of exterior seawall that is installed on a residential property is made of steel. Campus Insurance, a San Jose insurance company, is in the business of keeping you protected.
    Ervin Santana Jersey UK

    Comment by Ervin Santana Jersey UK — April 22, 2017 @ 9:31 pm

  32. So even if you are someone who wants to connect with its friends or home on line or a business house wants to promote its products online, all the items is feasible within a matter of couple of clicks. You run hard to it, and reaching, drive it hard and fast down the side line, missing it by an inch. Let us suppose you made the shot down the sideline.The correct auto insurance policy can help get you back on the road quickly if your car is damaged with their San Jose based Umbrella Insurance. Without a good health insurance, your family might be at the mercy of medical bills from only one serious illness or injury.
    Philippe Mexes Jersey UK

    Comment by Philippe Mexes Jersey UK — April 22, 2017 @ 9:33 pm

  33. 2 millionSome of the best multiplication gamesHarpold Yoshimura   Submitted 2014 01 15 10:22:51 In the 21st century, many people like to make use of their free time to play video clip games. Kaka (Orlando City): $7.S. There are many different ways and programs that can help you lower your monthly cost when you are trying to buy car insurance in Fremont. The main two systems people make use of to play video games are units and personal computer systems or PCs.
    Hakeem Olajuwon Jersey

    Comment by Hakeem Olajuwon Jersey — April 22, 2017 @ 9:36 pm

  34. For comparison: the everyday participant of vintage PC gaming currently taking onward them one $ 37 a year, moreover a friends of consoles and gi less $ 20. Its time be proud of our families again no matter how senile they may be!Of course having your parents live with you works extremely well if you actually get along with them. Se ha preocupado por ella ?.Hazard’s current deal does not expire until 2017, but Chelsea is offering a new five year deal to stave off interest from other clubs.The correct auto insurance policy can help get you back on the road quickly if your car is damaged with their San Jose based Umbrella Insurance.
    Karlos Dansby Jersey

    Comment by Karlos Dansby Jersey — April 22, 2017 @ 9:54 pm

  35. This piece of writing will help the internet people for creating new webpage or even a blog from start to end.

    Comment by Abby — April 23, 2017 @ 12:20 am

  36. Within th? fir?t month ?f ?t? use ??u ?h?u?d b? ?b?e to lose around 12lbs on average. Modify the blend if that turns into extremely dirty. Wells Fargo, San Bernardino Superior Court Case No.You could make a lot happen for the company to spend your time writing books, following up with clients, creating content, holding boot camps, etc.Murphy received criticism from the New York media for his decision to leave the club.

    Comment by Cheap Jerseys — April 23, 2017 @ 12:26 am

  37. You ?h?u?d not delay ?n? longer. Students under sponsorship who do not perform are deprived of the privilege which is then granted to the deserving people. She has an advanced degree in engineering and over twenty years making technology decisions for fortune 500 companies.Buy EquipmentThe servicecould also offer recommendations on which equipment would be best forthe particular printing that the business specializes in.If you want to acquire this kind of assist for the easy remedies for the negative debts you have to repay, then you can either sign on to the sites of the debt management companies where they’ve got revealed almost all the information on their services as well as notify exactly how to file for their own help online.
    Cheap NFL Jerseys

    Comment by Cheap NFL Jerseys — April 23, 2017 @ 1:43 am

  38. It can actually be a relaxing experience (as long as you agree beforehand that you are leaving all of the fish at the store!)The next time you are looking for a rainy day activity, put the slickers and goulashes on and go fishing at the aquarium!7. J.HCMillerPress. Also, they are accessible online on the web sites along with the websites which are presently there for your assist.com/Category: AdviceKeywords: Questions To Ask A Contractor,Hiring A Contractor,How To Hire A ContractorMariners Excited About Xavier Averys Speed – RealGM WiretapThe Seattle Mariners are excited about the speed Xavier Avery can bring to their lineup.

    Comment by Cheap Jerseys Wholesale — April 23, 2017 @ 7:39 am

  39. This is a great way to get kids interested in the foods that they eat and to discuss nutrition.There are wonderful opportunities to talk about health and to see new and interesting things at farmers markets.When shopping for fake tanning products, point out how long you want to be seen with a darker skin tone. The solution to thisissue is to buy a used printing press.Pack some of your favorite healthy snacks, grab a sweater and catch a fun flick.
    Cheap Jerseys China Wholesale

    Comment by Cheap Jerseys China Wholesale — April 23, 2017 @ 9:13 am

RSS feed for comments on this post. TrackBack URL

Leave a comment

**Mean or otherwise out-of-line comments will be deleted. That’s just how we roll.


blog | advice | comics | animation | goodies | to do | archive | about us

Breakup Girl created by Lynn Harris & Chris Kalb
© 2008 Just Friends Productions, Inc.
| privacy policy
Cool Aid!

Important Breakup Girl Maxim:
Breakup Girl Sez


Powered by WordPress