Big To Do
About Us

“Saving Love Lives The World Over!” e-mail e-mail to a friend in need

September 23, 2008

Can’t afford to stay, can’t afford to leave

Filed under: Treats — posted by Breakup Girl @ 9:23 am

Here, from FOBG Mary Beth Williams at Salon.com, a dismaying/touching account of the penny-pinch of heartbreak:

Sep. 22, 2008 | My marital separation would be so much easier if I were in a better income bracket. Then again, if I were in a better income bracket, maybe my husband and I wouldn’t be separating at all. I could rattle off all the reasons why the man that I promised to love forever is not sleeping next to me tonight. I can list all the heartaches we’ve endured over the last two years. Or I could cut to the chase and tell you that this is a story about money.

We saved and scrimped and searched for three years before sinking everything we had and more into a home for ourselves and our two children, a tiny co-op in a fringy New York City neighborhood. The process left us emotionally and financially tapped. Then, three days before we closed on the apartment, my husband lost his job.

Ultimately, it wasn’t the mortgage or job search or the way we both had to hustle for freelance work or the piled-up bills that did us in, although those things were a kick in the teeth. All those indignities we might have endured, though, had we endured them together. Instead, the stress and the pain and the lost self-esteem and inevitable and often crippling psychic toll of our strained circumstances contaminated our lives and brought out something in both of us that we couldn’t come back from. The harder we tried to be brave, the further apart we grew.

It may well be that if this financial and subsequent emotional crisis hadn’t driven a wedge between us, something else would have eventually done the job. It’s certainly fair to say that we’re not the same people we were when we married a decade and a half ago, in our mid-20s. But even if our financial disasters weren’t the cause of our breakup, they sure were the catalyst.

Yet they’ve likewise made us think long and hard about the consequences of ending it. I have spent hours at my desk, ruefully contemplating my Quicken spreadsheet, calculating my monthly income and expenses, trying to make the numbers turn out better. Emotionally, I couldn’t afford to stay in this marriage any longer. Financially, I don’t know how I’ll be able to afford to leave it.

Before I actually became one of those people whose marriage breaks up, I had a very simplistic notion of separation. It was a scene in a movie, one where the music swells and a woman stands tearfully looking out a window while a man in an overcoat tosses a suitcase into a taxi. Here’s the reality: It’s not like checking out of a hotel. And if it’s a movie, it’s more like “Dead Man Walking. ”

Long after we first broached the painful subject, my husband and I were still planning how to finesse our separation. It took weeks of discussion and more than one heavily annotated chart. Grief is not merely quantifiable; it can be PowerPointed. On the upside, the logistics of our unraveling have spurred us to communicate with a candor and spirit of cooperation that has been friendlier and more generous than almost anything that precipitated it. And it forced us to rely, heavily, on the charity of others.

Our separation is not a tidy business of someone going off to his quaint bachelor digs. Mostly my husband has been staying with his elderly parents, a few towns over, an arrangement that nobody’s enthusiastic about. At other times, we’ve cobbled together alternative accommodations. When our friends down the hall went away for two weeks, we traded off staying in their apartment, a situation that was unusual but which provided maximum access to our children. Later we made plans for him to stay at a Brooklyn musician friends’ apartment, but when the guy’s tour was canceled, we were sent scrambling for last-minute backup options. We’ve even had an awkward night when I went to a play with a girlfriend, returning late and sleeping on the couch while he slept in our bedroom. And if you’re looking for me next week, I will be taking up residence in another friend’s Upper West Side apartment during her vacation. This isn’t just a separation; it’s the Separation World Tour 2008, sponsored by Samsonite and the New York City Metropolitan Transit Authority.

We still split the expenses. When I think about shouldering them alone I can barely breathe. I can’t pay a mortgage single-handedly. I don’t even know if I can give up our family phone plan. Some days, I look at the bills and wonder, is losing my rollover minutes the price I have to pay for freedom? He and I have conversations galore, but we still haven’t figured anything out that feels equitable and practical.

I have lived most of my adult on a limited income, have budgeted and penny-pinched and done without. I rarely go to restaurants or buy new clothes. Yet even the few indulgences I once enjoyed — a once-a-week mocha, an occasional new book — now feel out of reach. I am taking the pittance I put aside every month for my daughters’ college education and redirecting it toward the day-to-day cost of living. I watch as the shabby IKEA kitchen cabinets sag precariously. They will likely soon fall apart completely, and I don’t know how I’ll ever be able to replace them. The fridge is on the fritz. They need school supplies and fall clothes. Beats me how it’ll happen. The burden of this choice, the potential for utter ruin, haunts me constantly.

Breakups are painful and crappy even in the best of circumstances. My two close friends of reasonably independent financial means rail over the endless minutiae of splitting expenses with their exes. My happily remarried college pal still describes her youthful divorce as “an amputation.” They’re the ones who got off easier. Another friend and her estranged husband had to live together for two years in a miserable state of marital limbo, because they simply couldn’t afford to split up the family. And a fellow mom from the playground confided recently that she’s spent the past year wanting to leave her marriage, but how could she and her kids survive on her salary?

In most of history and even now in most of the world, a woman walking away from a marriage has been unthinkable. Autonomy is rarely an option. Hell, I’m doing it, and it still feels like a long shot. I’m still not convinced that the mere possibility of mutual happiness apart from each other is a noble or practical enough goal. I worry that I am limiting my children’s lives, that in addition to all the emotional baggage of not having Mom and Dad across from them at the dinner table, they will have to make all kinds of material sacrifices they didn’t sign up for. I ask myself every day if my kids would be happier with two brave souls sticking it out but keeping them more secure than they could possibly be with a primary caregiver whose chances of plummeting into poverty just went through the occasionally leaky roof.

And yet, when I was still in the contemplative stage of the process, the notion of staying in something because it was more financially advantageous struck me as hopelessly cynical and downright mean. I saw us growing older and sadder. I saw something that had been wonderful and good and loving for so long becoming twisted into something mercenary and suffocating, dwindling into a joyless splitting of the electricity bill and the groceries. I saw two goodhearted people, who had brought two hilarious and beautiful children into the world, at a point when the only right and kind thing to do seemed to be to take the craziest fiscal gamble imaginable. I couldn’t save my marriage. I am having a hell of a time saving money. But I might be able to save, at least, the rest of our lives.

— By Mary Elizabeth Williams


  1. Wholesale Michael Crabtree Jerseys
    eujCheap Jerseys free shipping rodf z h m l

    Comment by BryanBug — May 22, 2017 @ 12:31 pm

  2. For example, you will encounter a higher entry cost compared to when you choose residential units. The problem is that usually the lesser the player, the less audio it can hold.The trouble is situated inside the vicious loop of the lifestyles that are very hectic to leave room for nutritious dwelling. With the higher risk comes a higher rate of return. Great customer service also.

    Comment by Wholesale Jerseys — May 22, 2017 @ 4:17 pm

  3. Thanks for sharing such a good thinking, piece of writing
    is nice, thats why i have read it completely

    Comment by credit card debt — May 22, 2017 @ 4:24 pm

  4. We do want to be able to move with, and play with, our grandchildren or nieces and nephews.At the end of the day, we are talking about a slippery slope with regard to so much of America’s and the globe’s appetite, greed, addiction and or depression. In 1963 Philips presented the audio cassette tape, which in turn pivoted the rage and wrath towards that marketplace, as a replacement of the radio. He was awarded the Society for Marketing Advances Distinguished Scholar Award for 2002 and is one of the most frequently cited marketing professors worldwide, his Google Scholar citation rate exceeded 560 in 2011.Balloons are symbolic of something good and nice.
    Wholesale NFL Jerseys [url=http://www.cheapestjerseysonwholesale.com/]Wholesale NFL Jerseys[/url]

    Comment by Wholesale NFL Jerseys — May 22, 2017 @ 4:48 pm

  5. Thiѕ iѕ very attention-grabbing, Үоu’гe an overly professional blogger.
    I haѵe joined your rss feed and sit up for searching
    fоr mοre of your wonderful post. Additionally, ӏ’ve shared yߋur site in my social networks

    Comment by antalya escort bayan — May 22, 2017 @ 6:30 pm

  6. GoDaddy provides a quantity of companies and just probably be tempted to produce a single additional buy. They think that computers not only can they operate a lot more unable to function properly utilize them and achieve going to be the registry usually which you can use.”I threw a bullpen today and I didn’t miss a spot,” Harvey said Wednesday evening during an interview on ESPN New York 98. when you have completely nothing to enter there, then you should begin searching for any GoDaddy promo code prior to finishing your buy!These are simple to locate and use. I say arrest this obesity epidemic now, and yes, earmark funds for public awareness programs and treatments.

    Comment by Cheap Authentic NFL Jerseys — May 22, 2017 @ 9:21 pm

  7. If a multi functional necessary necessary usually deleted based on going to be the software,you may possibly on no account be the case able for additional details on reactivate your repair the problem and all your family members not only can they have to restore all your family members full and complete main system You not only can they discover that there are several different software programs available available on the web to understand more about clean your registry.”The Billy BeaneJoe Stiglich of The Oakland Tribune: “For someone drawing so much attention with his play, Brandon Allen’s quiet nature deflects the spotlight when he’s off the field. You are able to attach to some ecommerce website with the help of a dropship program and your clients can buy different products from the website and you just have to get the fee and facilitate the orders. Brain damage can occur when the head is pushed strongly against the skull, such as with whiplash.Author Bio: You can buy Cheap MP3 Players online from us.
    Wholesale NFL Jerseys

    Comment by Wholesale NFL Jerseys — May 22, 2017 @ 10:15 pm

  8. Additional solutions that are offered from the company should be carefully weighted as well. ‘He’s hard to take out of the lineup. People who make indeed time to prepare whole meals at home, people that acquire organic items and just take care of their spiritual growth in parallel with the care they offer to your physique, truly make sacrifices. Hughes had two homers and five RBI Sunday, as the Twins ended a sevengame losing streak with an 114 victory over the Tigers in front of the 57th announced sellout crowd of the season at Target Field. All independent and experienced, the movers will always strive to surpass expectstions.

    Comment by Cheap Jerseys — May 23, 2017 @ 2:53 am

  9. The result was a fiveinning, 11 tie that left the Yankees fuming as they raced to catch a flight out of town before the airports were closed. I will highly advise it, this is a wonderful value!”. You can also get help to find a brain injury lawyer at braininjury. With this in mind it is important always to make use of printers that offer professional printing and balloon services as a package. “They didn’t care about you; that’s what they showed me.
    Cheap NFL Jerseys

    Comment by Cheap NFL Jerseys — May 23, 2017 @ 4:02 am

  10. Hey would you mind stating which blog platform you’re working with?

    I’m planning to start my own blog in the near future but I’m having a
    hard time selecting between BlogEngine/Wordpress/B2evolution and Drupal.
    The reason I ask is because your design seems different then most blogs and I’m looking for something unique.

    P.S Sorry for being off-topic but I had to ask!

    Comment by airtronic.co.za — May 23, 2017 @ 6:30 am

  11. I was able to find good advice from your articles.

    Comment by Clarita — May 23, 2017 @ 6:44 am

  12. Repeated brain injuries have a cumulative effect resulting in more severe and more prolonged postconcussion symptoms.Create a huntsy profile. Voice Recording: Youll find allot of Audio players that have a voicerecording function. We will resort to our resolve and discipline and reap the rich rewards, all without ever needing to cheat. To find official Georgia Tech merchandise, you can visit his store at

    Comment by Wholesale Jerseys — May 23, 2017 @ 8:30 am

  13. Historians say the name, spelled as one word, was first used to describe supporters who attended Tech athletic events, dressed in yellow coats and jackets. The media needs to search out those who would balance out the negative headlines and showcase the many ball players, military, and business people that play by the rules and enjoy a lifestyle befitting them and their labor contributions. All independent and experienced, the movers will always strive to surpass expectstions. Yes, yes, yes, We Can Do It Women!?Author’s Resource BoxDebra L. Hughes had two homers and five RBI Sunday, as the Twins ended a sevengame losing streak with an 114 victory over the Tigers in front of the 57th announced sellout crowd of the season at Target Field.
    Wholesale NFL Jerseys Cheap

    Comment by Wholesale NFL Jerseys Cheap — May 23, 2017 @ 9:44 am

  14. Time will tell the full story of Bernie Madoff, and the myriad other Ponzi scheme architects, yet I suspect that decisions became more and more laced with optimism about addwaterandstir wealth. Most of these victims were in high school. There is also lack of agreement on what amount of time should pass before athletes can safely return to sports.Author’s Resource BoxLegalView. In addition, one does not need to deal with any kind of product shipping, customer returns, inventory, as well as any other associated issues.
    Wholesale Jerseys China

    Comment by Wholesale Jerseys China — May 23, 2017 @ 9:44 am

  15. I’m really impressed with your writing skills as well as with the layout on your blog.
    Is this a paid theme or did you modify it yourself? Anyway keep
    up the nice quality writing, it’s rare to see a
    great blog like this one today.

    Comment by broadband in my area — May 23, 2017 @ 10:22 am

  16. Hi there it’s me, I am also visiting this site on a regular basis, this web page
    is genuinely fastidious and the users are actually
    sharing good thoughts.

    Comment by aitu8.com — May 23, 2017 @ 1:24 pm

  17. canadian pharmacy cialis deals

    cialis cheap

    cilais price

    cialis 5 mg comprar venezuela

    Comment by SethChums — May 23, 2017 @ 2:23 pm

  18. All these factors require a lot of time and planning. This is because you have to do more than just changing the paint on the walls or the floor covering.If all your family members worry about carry out an all in one cleaning software,gps device one that allows all your family members for more information about back right your fix the problem The registry as you can imagine would be the fact an all in one complicated configuration that needs in order to get treated carefully. This condition is called secondimpact syndrome (SIS). Custom fitted mouth pieces may also help prevent concussions in contact sports.

    Comment by Cheap Jerseys — May 23, 2017 @ 2:29 pm

  19. Just start looking for reductions, which really assist to save. I am eager to throw a life preserver to you in the form of education and cheer leading regarding your money. Schedules of work allow meeting of deadlines and response time needs to be reduced drastically. the cause for this, the reductions can be located in truth will come in hand. A helluva, helluva, helluva, helluva, hell of an engineer.
    Wholesale Hockey Jerseys

    Comment by Wholesale Hockey Jerseys — May 23, 2017 @ 3:37 pm

  20. I visit everyday a few blogs and blogs to read
    articles or reviews, however this weblog provides quality based

    Comment by bbs.guanjindai.com — May 23, 2017 @ 4:15 pm

  21. payday loans fast online

    payday loans

    payday loans

    cash advance rochester mn

    Comment by MaoisesChums — May 23, 2017 @ 6:33 pm

  22. You will find hundreds of merchandise that happen to be at present marketed for weight loss.com for more helpful information about Helpful Tips Before Choosing Commercial Investment Properties. Congratulations on reintroducing the word NO back into our language, and meaning it. Not to mention its fragrance that entices your sense of smell, its robust taste confirmed by your sense of taste as you take your very first sip of it.Owners in most major cities have plenty of providers to sort through.

    Comment by Wholesale Jerseys From China — May 23, 2017 @ 7:17 pm

RSS feed for comments on this post. TrackBack URL

Leave a comment

**Mean or otherwise out-of-line comments will be deleted. That’s just how we roll.


blog | advice | comics | animation | goodies | to do | archive | about us

Breakup Girl created by Lynn Harris & Chris Kalb
© 2008 Just Friends Productions, Inc.
| privacy policy
Cool Aid!

Important Breakup Girl Maxim:
Breakup Girl Sez


Powered by WordPress